CHLSS

Donate
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  •  
Menu
  • Adoption
    • DI Uber 2.1Infant Adoption
    • A father and son created through foster care adoption embrace.Foster Care Adoption
    • Young girl from China smiles at the camera.International Adoption
    • Close
  • Foster Care
    • Three siblings in foster care smile in the part with their arms wrapped around each other's shoulders.Foster Care
    • An African American single woman wraps her arms around two brothers she adopted from foster care.Foster Care Adoption
    • Close
  • Pregnancy Services
    • Birth parents and adoptive parents smile with son.Open Adoption
    • parenting2Parenting
    • A father holds a football for his infant child.Birth Fathers
    • Happy woman and man waiting to adopt a child.Waiting Family Profiles
    • Close
  • Post Adoption
    • Domestic Post Adoption ServicesDomestic Post Adoption
    • International Post Adoption ServicesInternational Post Adoption
    • Post Adoption ResourcesPost Adoption Resources
    • A teen boy who was adopted from Korea as an infant smiles against a stone wall.Post Placement Reports
    • Close
  • Education & Events
    • An Ethiopian adoptee and her sister smile and hug.Education & Events Calendar
    • A woman attends a webinar.Recorded Webinars
    • Close
  • Donate
Home / Blog / News / Centering the Adoptee Experience in Adoption Narratives

Centering the Adoptee Experience in Adoption Narratives

January 28, 2021 by Creating a Family

We are thankful for the adult adoptees who share their experiences to educate and support us as we learn how to parent our adopted and foster children well. This guest post highlights thoughts from a member of the Creating A Family online community who has been a consistent advocate for centering the adoptee in adoption narratives and accepting the adoptee’s whole experience. We need these reminders to “listen to it all,” not just the stuff that makes us adoptive parents feel good – or better – about our shared stories.

Why Must Adoptees be Grateful?

There is a well-known saying by the Rev. Keith C Griffith: “Adoption loss is the only trauma in the world where the victims are expected by the whole of society to be grateful.”

Quite commonly, adoptees are not only not allowed to feel any sense of loss surrounding their adoptions. Instead, they are expected to be grateful for adoption. There may also be, alongside that denial of their loss, a sense that they don’t have the same right to ask for things that others might ask for. That is to say, the two often co-exist in the adoptee experience.

When society discusses things like “nature vs. nurture” in terms of an adoptee’s development, the message conveyed is that nurture must overcome nature. This messaging can make the adoptee feel that his most core self is of little or no value. What is decent and good about him results from the nurture given to him by his adoptive parents.

Adoptees are adaptees.

It can be said that adoptees are also often adaptees. They are the ones in the new relationships with adoptive families who do the most adapting. For example, with international and transracial adoptions, adoptees are the ones who must move to a new country. They are expected to fit in: with a new family, to new sights, sounds and smells, to new foods, new habits and routines, and so on.

Many international and transracial adoptive parents have very few adaptations to make in their lifestyles if any at all. Granted, some do move to different locations to surround their adoptee with racial mirrors and increased diversity. Discussions about that choice to move are met with exclamations of how lucky the adoptee is to have what he has in his adoptive parents.

Adoptees are compliant.

The ideal adoptee is still often lauded as the compliant one in relationships, putting others before herself. It isn’t necessarily her parents who raise her to believe that others are “more deserving” than she is. But if she’s been raised to adapt and be grateful, she very likely has internalized that complying and “going along” is the way to be.

I think my parents did a great job raising me as a healthy adoptee, but I find that I have been guilty of “going along” myself. On the flip side, when I speak up in adoption circles to center the adoptee’s experience, I have been labeled as selfish and accused of not seeing “the other side” (that is, the adoptive parents’ side). As I’m learning, the truth is that often adoptees are expected to see the other side before our own experience is acknowledged as valuable.

Whose Best Interest Has Really Been Served?

Another aspect of society’s difficulty to center the adoptee experience is our post-war form of Western adoption. The institute of adoption has been built upon severing connections to create new ones. It’s as if our existence post-adoption is the only part of ourselves that matters to the whole of culture.

For example, the sealing of adoption records has been perpetuated more to make adopting parents feel safe and comfortable than with an eye toward the adoptee’s needs or even those of the birth parents. And currently, the fight for adoptees’ right to original birth and adoption records is regularly weighed up against whether it is in the best interest of the other members of the triad first.

Are We Reforming Adoption or Reframing It?

I certainly think open adoptions are preferable to closed adoptions. There seems to be quite a broad definition of open adoption and varies widely per family, to be fair. Apparently, one can consider their child’s adoption to be “open” even if the birth parent(s) and adoptive parents barely know each other, have no contact, or if the child is not involved in the relationship. I have even seen “open adoption” to describe a meeting between birth parents and prospective parents before or during birth, with no contact after the child is adopted.

As an adoptee, I personally don’t think one can call an adoption “open” unless the child knows her birth parents. Those forms of “open adoption” seem to be a panacea for the adults (the adoptive parents) to ensure that the adopted child will feel nothing but happiness. These kinds of re-definitions — or wide-ranging definitions — seem to be part of a move away from real reform of adoption to “reframing” of adoption. It’s almost as if we are saying, “if we talk about it in positive terms, then everyone will be happy about it.”

The Danger of Rainbows and Unicorns

As a result, I am sometimes concerned that today’s young adoptees might feel like they are in an emotional straitjacket. I worry that they will hear the message that they must not have anything other than positive feelings about their adoption experience. When “magical thinking” and “destiny” talk is how we talk about adoption, the adoptee may feel even more obliged to feel nothing but positivity regarding her adoption story.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Yes, adoption may be warm, loving, and healthy. But leaving it there is an incomplete message. Adoption is also painful, rooted in loss, and challenging. To deny these feelings and conflicting experiences is a disservice to adoptees and to the experience of adoption for all. Creating a Family is grateful to adult adoptees like this guest author, who show us how to sit with both the hard and the good of the adoptee experience.

This article was originally published by Creating a Family on January 20, 2021. View original post here. 

Filed Under: News

Categories

  • Adoptee Reflections
  • Adoption Legislation
  • Adoptive Family Stories
  • Birth Parent Reflections
  • Culture and Heritage
  • Donor Stories
  • Education & Webinars
  • Events
  • Foster Care
  • Foster Care Adoption
  • Global Family Support
  • Infant Adoption
  • International Adoption
  • News
  • Parenting
  • Reunion
  • Sibling Adoption
  • Today's Child and Family
  • Waiting Children
  • Waiting Families
Subscribe today
Join Our Mailing List
Subscribe today

Join our Mailing List

    You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us at publisher@chlss.org. We will treat your information with respect. For more information about our privacy practices, please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Help a child thrive
Contribute Today
Help a child thrive

Main Office

1605 Eustis Street
Saint Paul, MN 55108
651.646.7771
800.952.9302
welcome@chlss.org

Maryland Office

15800 Crabbs Branch Way Suite 300
Rockville, MD 20855
301.562.6500
inquire@chlss.org

Virginia Office

4101 Chain Bridge Road, Suite 301
Fairfax, Virginia 22030
703.642.2193
inquire@chlss.org

FacebookTwitterPintrestYouTubeInstagram
coa-logo
coa-logo
NCFA Member Seal_ Gray
NCFA Member Seal_ Gray

© 2021 Children's Home Society and Lutheran Social Service of Minnesota. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy policy Developed by Vivid Image Staff Login

Cookies

This site uses cookies: Find out more.